Quiet blue-gray tidal river curving past pine woods and tawny shoreline grasses on a clear autumn morning in coastal North Carolina.

The Mallory Creek Commute Now Has a Draft Bridge Toll

A buyer comparing Mallory Creek Plantation with a home in Wilmington now has a draft price for the bridge between them. NCDOT's environmental assessment for a replacement Cape Fear Memorial Bridge assumes a $2 toll per trip for cars starting in 2030. The rate would rise each year with the consumer price index. Nothing about the toll is final. Against the cross-river price gap, though, the number is small. What a toll would change is the cost of one particular commute, and a Mallory Creek address sits close to the center of it.

The same assessment says which drivers would find the new bridge worth paying for and which would use the free route. That split depends on where in Wilmington you drive to each morning, and it is worth working out before you write an offer on either side of the river.

The $2 Figure Is a Planning Assumption

NCDOT lists the replacement, project HB-0039, as in development. Its project page puts construction start and completion dates as TBD. Two designs are still under review. Alternative A is a movable span with 65 feet of clearance when closed and 135 feet when raised. Revised Alternative B is a fixed span 135 feet above the river. Both would have three 12-foot lanes in each direction and a 15-foot multi-use path, according to Coastal Review. NCDOT puts the revised fixed-span design at $1.02 billion.

On the money side, the project has a $242 million federal grant that must be obligated by September 2027, plus $85 million from the state legislature. Officials currently plan to cover the rest with tolls. The Wilmington Urban Area Metropolitan Planning Organization has voted twice since 2024 to keep tolling on the table, and WHQR reported that NCDOT adopted the replacement as a tolled project in July 2025. This July, NCDOT rejected a private proposal to build the bridge.

The environmental assessment says actual rates would be set closer to opening by the board of the North Carolina Turnpike Authority. Treat $2 as the planners' working figure, not a quote.

Your Wilmington Destination Decides Who Pays

The assessment's traffic study splits cross-river drivers by where they are going. Drivers between Leland or Belville and the Silver Lake area south of Wilmington would be the most likely to stay on the Memorial Bridge, because it saves them the most time. Drivers between Navassa and east Wilmington, near UNC Wilmington and Wilmington Marketplace, would be more likely to take the Isabel Holmes Bridge by way of Martin Luther King Jr. Parkway.

Mallory Creek Plantation is inside Leland's town limits, on the Winnabow side between Wilmington and Southport. A resident who works in south Wilmington is making the trip the study expects to stay on the tolled bridge. For that driver, the toll would buy the time savings the bridge exists to provide.

A Mallory Creek resident who works near UNCW faces a different choice: pay for the faster crossing, or join the traffic heading north to Isabel Holmes. Buyers looking at Grayson Park, outside Leland, or Magnolia Greens, off US 17 South, make the same calculation. The answer depends on their own address and their own office.

Isabel Holmes Is Where the Overflow Goes

The assessment expects about 90% of drivers who avoid the toll to shift to the Isabel Holmes Bridge, mostly reaching it from Third Street in Wilmington. It projects weekday traffic on Isabel Holmes rising about 43% in 2030. I-140, MLK Parkway, US 421 and South Third Street would also carry more traffic. The same passage says fewer drivers would divert as overall traffic grows, because the time saved would make the toll easier to justify.

The region got a preview in 2024, when repairs closed the Memorial Bridge's inbound lanes and then its outbound lanes. Before the work began, the StarNews listed the Isabel Holmes Bridge, MLK Parkway, College Road and I-140 as the detours. During the eastbound closure, Brunswick County EMS told WECT that ambulance trips toward Isabel Holmes went from 20 minutes to 30. For the westbound closure, NCDOT added triple left-turn lanes from North College Road onto MLK Parkway and an extra lane on US 421 South at the Thomas Rhodes Bridge in Leland, WECT reported.

The 2024 closures pushed every crossing onto other routes for a few months, while the toll scenario moves only part of the traffic, year after year. In both cases the overflow lands on Isabel Holmes and the roads that feed it.

Set the Toll Beside the Price Gap

At $2 each way, a round trip costs $4. Over roughly 250 workdays, that is about $1,000 a year at the starting rate, before any CPI increases, and no earlier than 2030. Compare that with what the two counties' single-family homes sold for this year, from Cape Fear REALTORS' local market reports.

Single-family, Cape Fear REALTORS New Hanover County Brunswick County
Median sales price, September 2026 $478,123 $444,953
Median sales price, January through September 2026 $494,910 $423,850
Days on market, September 2026 51 75
Homes for sale, September 2026 832 2,477
Months of supply, September 2026 3.2 5.3

The September medians were $33,170 apart. Across the first nine months of 2026, the gap was $71,060. Even the narrower September figure equals more than 30 years of tolls at the $1,000-a-year starting rate. These are countywide numbers, not Mallory Creek prices, and a specific home can be well above or below its county median. Still, the toll is a small line item next to the purchase price.

The two medians moved in opposite directions. The Brunswick median rose 8.5% from September 2025 to September 2026, and the New Hanover median fell 1.5%. That narrowed the gap this fall. A buyer counting on a large cross-river discount should price the specific homes they are comparing instead of relying on the year-to-date figure. Our look at Leland's rising prices and slower sales explains what is pushing the Brunswick side.

Brunswick Buyers Have More Room to Negotiate

The supply figures may matter more than any toll. In September 2026, Brunswick County had 2,477 single-family homes for sale, nearly three times New Hanover's 832. It had 5.3 months of supply against 3.2. Brunswick homes took 75 days to sell, compared with 51 in New Hanover. Through the first nine months of 2026, Brunswick homes averaged 88 days on market, up from 75 in the same stretch of 2025.

More homes for sale and longer marketing times generally give buyers more room to ask for things, while Brunswick sellers still received 98.4% of list price on average in September 2026. For a buyer whose commute fits the Memorial Bridge, that negotiating room is available today, and the toll in NCDOT's planning numbers would not start before 2030.

Key Dates Before a Toll Could Start

The dates below come from NCDOT's project schedule, reporting by Coastal Review, and NCDOT Division 3's October 2026 project list.

  1. December 4, 2026. The public comment period on Alternative A and Revised Alternative B closes. Comments go through NCDOT's public input page.
  2. Early 2027. NCDOT expects to choose an alternative and reach a federal environmental finding.
  3. April 15, 2027. Bids are scheduled to open on a reduced-conflict intersection at US 17 and Governors Road/Green Hill Road, a contract letting date rather than a closure schedule.
  4. September 2027. The deadline to obligate the $242 million federal grant.
  5. December 21, 2027. Bids are scheduled to open for preservation work on the US 17 bridge over US 74/76.
  6. 2030. The first year of the $2 toll in NCDOT's planning numbers.

Quick Answers

How much busier would the Isabel Holmes Bridge get? The assessment projects weekday traffic there rising about 43% in 2030 under the toll scenario, with roughly 90% of drivers who leave the Memorial Bridge heading to Isabel Holmes.

Does the design choice change the Mallory Creek commute? Both designs have the same six lanes and multi-use path. The difference is on the Wilmington side, where Revised Alternative B was redesigned to keep bridge traffic on Third Street, according to Coastal Review.

The figures here are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm your own costs with the right professional before you rely on them.

If you're weighing Mallory Creek against a Wilmington address, Living By The Coast Realty Group can map your daily drive, toll scenario included, alongside the homes you're comparing. If you already own on either side of the river, start with a free home valuation to see where your home stands while the bridge plans are still being decided.

Work With Us

With Over 40 Years of Closing Real Estate Deals, the Living by The Coast Realty Group Is a Top Producing Real Estate Team in Coastal Southeast North Carolina that Continually Provides Our Clients with The Upmost Care and Representation at Every Phase.

Follow Me on Instagram